The Space Between


Dave Matthews‘ father was a physicist who worked for IBM in the 1970s.  Matthews explores The Space Between with an emotional depth likely influenced by the loss of his father to cancer, and the subsequent loss of his sister in a murder/suicide at the hand of her husband.  The emptiness in that space is a palpable void.

Palpable space that emerges by emptiness filling in binocularly is more rapturous though no less emotional, the substance of which Sue Barry has elevated to public awareness.  Sue begins her TEDx talk with the following observation: “When I was 48 years old, I learned to see in a whole new way.  And in fact, in a way that most doctors and scientists said I could not possibly learn.”

At about the same time that Sue’s book Fixing My Gaze shot to #4 among Amazon’s best-selling science books of 2009, a research workshop on Cognitive and Developmental Factors in Perceptual Constancy was being held at the University of Pennsylvania.  Invited participants, including psychologists and philosophers, were asked to examine how we tease apart cognitive and phenomenal factors in people’s responses to a variety of spatial properties.  The essence of that workshop was published in a volume from Oxford University Press in 2012, titled Visual Experience: Sensation, Cognition, and Constancy.

Visual Experience

Chapter 4 is a remarkable one, titled Constant Enough: On the Kinds of Perceptual Constancy Worth Having.  I say remarkable, because its authors have a section within it they call “One depth doesn’t fit all” in which they cite the case of Stereo Sue and discuss it in sufficient detail so that one gains the sense that Sue has engendered lively discussion within their corner of the vision research community.  Consider this quote (p. 89): “Her case is already highly controversial, because of the widespread belief that unused stereo channels atrophy completely.”

Call me shallow, but I enjoy plumbing the depths of such controversies.  They open up new insights into the space between.

2 thoughts on “The Space Between

  1. Another Ah-Ha moment involving the Space Between: When it comes to neural activity, there is a space between the stimulus and the response. Within that space is the ability to choose. When we are reflex-bound, there is very little time or ability to choose anything other than the pre-programmed response. Only, when our neural network becomes more mature through trial/error and experience, are we able to choose more wisely. There is a huge difference between our patients before going through vision therapy and those who have gone through it. The before crowd tends to be more rash and impulsive. The after crowd tends to be more calm and decisive.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s